Do I get Artorias' soul back if I kill Ciaran?
After defeating Artorias, you can find Ciaran paying her respects to the grave of Artorias. When you speak to her, she asks for the soul, so that she may "pay her proper respects".
If I give her the soul, and then kill her, do I get Artorias' soul back?
Best Answer
No! you dont get it back. If you trade the Soul and than can kill her you only get 10k Souls. The Artorias Soul is worth 16k so you will lose 6k Souls + what ever you think its her Death is worth. The only thing why you should trade the soul is if you want the swords without having to fight her.
Pictures about "Do I get Artorias' soul back if I kill Ciaran?"
What happens if you kill Ciaran Dark Souls?
There are no known benefits besides those of moral conscience for giving her Artorias' Soul instead of killing her. (she gives you her blades silver tracer and gold tracer in exchange, which can be obtained from her dead body).What happens if you give the Soul of Artorias to Ciaran?
If you give her his soul you get both of her weapons without having to deal with her. On the other hand, killing her grants you both weapons for free and allows access to her armor set.Is Ciaran in love with Artorias?
Plot. Ciaran appears after Artorias is defeated, asking the player for the Soul of Artorias. She rewards the player with the Gold Tracer and the Dark Silver Tracer if given the Soul of Artorias. It is possible that she was romantically involved with Artorias, before he was lost to the Abyss.Is Ciaran a human?
3) Ornstein, Artorias, Ciaran, Gough... They are not Human, or undead humans...[ThePruld] DARK SOULS LORE - Artorias
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Marta Wave, cottonbro, Elijah O'Donnell, Miriam Alonso