How to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings?

How to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings? - Crop mother washing hands of child in bathroom

I'm using Ferram Aerospace Research to add some realism to drag. But this makes me to use fairings for my payload.

Sad thing is, my payload swings. A lot. I tried both KW Rocketry and Procedural Fairings but both express the same behaviour. Without internal struts I can't make it to an orbit sometimes.

Placing internal struts is next to impossible, so is there any other way to have cargo secured? I know that mission failures caused by payload fairings happens in real life, but I think I had enough of them to feel realism already. There are some patents for securing cargo inside fairing (I mean real life USA and EU patents) - is there any way to get the same in KSP?

I mean, for example, something like CFLR here:

Image

Article with this image

To give the fairing structural support during the ascent, the "Centaur Forward Load Reactor" deck has been designed by Contraves. This aluminum ring extends from the Centaur to the fairing's inner wall. It separates in two halves moments after the fairing is jettisoned during launch.



Best Answer

The answer to this question and many other KSP questions is:

MORE STRUTS

Simple as that. Before placing the nose cone, place symmetrical struts from your payload to the fairing wall. I assume you're using fairing walls and not just the nose cone because your payload is large enough to swing.

I did this and was able to lift a large lander with enough fuel to land and return from Duna without it swinging.

If you're still getting swing consider assigning SAS to a control group, to disable it during launch.




Pictures about "How to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings?"

How to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings? - From above unrecognizable black man wearing protective mask on face of ethnic kid standing in room near window closed with curtain
How to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings? - Top view of pink ribbon representing cancer placed on yellow background among glass test tubes and flasks in light studio
How to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings? - Ribbon representing skin cancer with tube





How to stop things rolling around in your car!




More answers regarding how to prevent cargo from swinging inside fairings?

Answer 2

The only way is to make the cargo rigid enough it doesn't swing. And that means strutting usually (or simply make the cargo smaller, launching it in several launches and docking it together for example).

Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.

Images: Ketut Subiyanto, Ketut Subiyanto, Tara Winstead, Tara Winstead