Skyrim just doesn't want some NPCs to be killable
I've been trying to use the setessential command to mark NPCs as not essential (thus killable) but certain NPCs remain essential after using the command. These NPCs are: Jarl Balgruuf, Farengar Secret-Fire (or whatever his name is), Jorleif (Ulfric's steward), all of the leaders of the Companions, Sibbi Black-Briar, members of the Theives Guild, and maybe more, but I don't know at the moment. But why isn't the command working? I have the correct BaseID and everything.
Best Answer
So you want to kill Jarl Balgruuf...why? He is like a major part of the story too! But, as ChaseC said, you need a MOD if you are on PC version. I am pretty sure Nexus has one, and the steam store probably does too.
Although, if you want to kill Ulfric Stormcloak, (Spoiler)
you can do the Imperial Legion questline (It takes about an hour) and kill him in the end
Pictures about "Skyrim just doesn't want some NPCs to be killable"
How do you stop NPCs from being hostile in Skyrim?
EDIT: To stop random NPC's attacking you, just turn off Ai detection with ' tdetect ' and then click on the NPC and type ' setav aggression 0 '.How do you make an NPC not essential in Skyrim?
Usage of the 'setessential' console command is: setessential <base ID> <1/0> - set a character (NPC) as immortal (1) or mortal (0). Note that the base ID and not the ref ID must be used. The ref ID is what appears when clicking on an object with the console open.How do I disable essential NPCs?
For example, to remove Deacon's essential status, type help "Deacon" 4, then use the ID it lists for him in the above command. setessential <baseID> 0 \u2013 Allows the NPC to be permanently killed. setessential <baseID> 1 \u2013 Sets them to be unkillable.What happens if you kill important NPCs in Skyrim?
What you need to take note of is if you kill Anyone and a law abiding NPC sees it you will have a bounty due to that and all law abiding npcs will attack you ... and it may only be an accidental hit. Check your Crime level in the main menu and it will tell you how big your bounty is and in which hold.Can you play Skyrim without leaving Solitude?
More answers regarding skyrim just doesn't want some NPCs to be killable
Answer 2
Some story-based NPC's essential code cannot be changed. You must download a mod to over-ride these commands.
Answer 3
Just out of curiosity, have you tried console-killing them? (bring up the console, select them with your mouse, and type "kill?"). I'm guessing they will just fall over, be unconscious for a bit, and then get up again, but I've never really been curious enough to try.
FWIW, I agree with Aceofgods; if you kill essential characters that are central to the storyline, it will break the main quest, and they (Bethesda) probably put some safeguards in place to prevent that.
Answer 4
I'm not sure what you're trying to accomplish by killing them (e.g. do you just want to remove them from the game, or do you want to loot their items etc). However, if you want to do it purely to remove them from existence, you can do that very easily by opening the console (` or ~), clicking on them, typing in 'disable' (without quotes) and hitting enter. They will be removed from existence. And then if you ever want to bring them back, you can do so with 'enable'.
Answer 5
Whether or not you've completed a quest with them, you can't kill an essential character.
Sources: Stack Exchange - This article follows the attribution requirements of Stack Exchange and is licensed under CC BY-SA 3.0.
Images: Ketut Subiyanto, Los Muertos Crew, Thirdman, RODNAE Productions