testfor a fake player on a scoreboard

(I assume you are on 1.8+) Since you cannot test for a player that isn't in game, Try using an armorstand.

First, Summon an armorstand with the nbt tags NoGravity, Marker, and CustomName. (Ex. /summon ArmorStand ~ ~ ~ {NoGravity:1b,Marker:1b,CustomName:MobHunger}

To set it a scoreboard, you can use an entity selector in place of the player. This would work: scoreboard players set @e[type=ArmorStand,name=MobHunger] stats 1

You can also use an entity selector in the testfor command, it's just a bit different syntax. /testfor @e[type=ArmorStand,name=MobHunger,score_stats_min=1]

Also, just a tip: try transitioning over to the execute command rather than testfor, as with testfor you need an comparator and a different command that needs to target the entity (unless you need that comparator for lag or other purposes). With execute, you can do a command in the same command if it finds the armorstand with a score of 1 in stats. Ex. execute @e[type=ArmorStand,name=MobHunger,score_stats_min=1] ~ ~ ~ setblock ~ ~ ~ stone is much more efficient than using a comparator.

If you are on the 1.9 snapshots, you can use the scoreboard to test nonexistent players:
/scoreboard players test (playername) (objectivename) (min) (max)